This is a very HOT and sizzling story!! She might have gotten so excited and nervous and hot, and the butt plug felt amazing, perfectly in place, BUT females wear Stilettos or heels, which changes one's posture, and maybe it was the perfect sized butt plug (or a bit smaller?), but with all of that lube, and making out as if ya'll need a hotel room, rawrrr, and heels...It was just the 1st time adventure!! PLUS she had lubed it and placed it in the baggie, so the entire plug might have been so slippery maybe, during insertion? Depends on the size plug as well...In public, all of that extra lube feels uncomfortable to me !!
She isn't the lone ranger, lol...I have had this happen to me as well, a few times actually in public, under my clothes, where I felt like I had to adjust as I walked discreetly, with my BF/Lover/Dom next to me....eeeeks..ha ha.... It's MUCH better if the guy, YOU, parks the car in a dark parking lot close by the restaurant, club, bar, venue... And takes that butt plug, lubes the end, NO baggie, and according to prior steamy discussions, places a more cone shaped, longer plug, with a wider base, way up her bottom as she hikes up her short skirt and raises her ass, and spreads her ass cheeks for you, and you insert it for her slowly!!
(You can have wipes and lots of tissues handy, just in case) You can reassure her, because she needs your laughter and love and support to have fun and not be embarrassed that things didn't go perfectly!! Keep a light hearted, sexy attitude, and include a lot of anal play in bed with your manhood and perhaps toys and plugs, and this will relax her, right??? Practice makes puurrrrfect ;-)) wink wink
It might help if she wears snug-fitting sexy panties!!! Those help a lot!! (Um, I'm just saying that, bc I never wear panties, but it has helped a few times!!) I personally love wearing my shiny stainless steel anal hook, up my bottom (with a ball at the end to keep it in place), and the top of the eye of the hook attaches to rope or thin leather, and then attaches to my collar, up my back. I then wear it out, under my little black dress, black sheer lace push up bra, black garter, sheer stockings, Stilettos (cheetah print, spikey, or ANY ones will do, RED ), and only silver hoop earrings, and 2 rings, a watch, a nice bracelet, red lip gloss, and a smile.... No one knows what I am wearing, and no one even bats an eyelash about my collar, with my elegant dress. I must maintain my posture, or I can feel the ball of that anal hook move, and it's not a bother, but I prefer being a naughty Lady at that moment.
Ok, off the subject about keeping the butt plug in place, but it takes practice in public, and it's So fun and Naughty!!! ;-)))