Dr. Sky, I would say that it could amount to abuse, excepting that complaint is seeking a replication of his past experiences.
Sounds consensual to me. And, I dont throw stones at other people's kinks, as I would be buried under my own long history.
You and I hold a strong belief in safe, sane, and consensual play. You provide exemplary medical concerns to back upon your experiences in the ER, and share about what can get kinksters into serious medical trouble, if not in a coffin.
On the other hand, my background is based upon 40-years (off and on) of play in private, at parties, and while participating in edu programs at the Society of Janus, coupled with other educational workshops. 6 quarts seems
excessive; 2 quarts of warm water does the job nicely; repeat if necessary. 6 - 12- 18 strokes of
the cane be reasonable, but 300 like a female
friend took, left her disfigured for quite a while, though her denuded nether region was her red badge of courage for a while.
Doctor, you provide safe & sane information to a few of our family, and to the masses, and it is always hoped that you will speak up where there
are unsafe medical considerations.
Thank you -